I just bought brand new peanut butter and for the second time now, I did not actually look at my peanut butter jar before I bought it, so I accidentally bought crunchy peanut butter. I have nothing against crunchy, I just prefer creamy peanut butter on my toast in the mornings so I was a bit bummed to realize I had purchased crunchy! I did this one other time so you’d think I would remember to check the label but I never do! So since I have an entire jar of peanut butter to use up before I can buy another one I decided to find some peanut buttery recipes to try! I have never made no-bake cookies before but I have had them at parties or when my coworkers have made them and in my wanderings I found a recipe that I had all the ingredients for and decided to go for it. No baking involved even (obviously since it is no-bake) so it was super easy!
20 minutes, including cool time in the freezer, and these guys were done. I did put the plate back in to cool them a bit more, but they were at least cool enough to peel off the parchment paper. Another tray in the fridge isn’t shown here because it was still cooling. I only made a half-recipe and still got tons of cookies!